Skip to main content
Los Angeles Orthopedic
Patient case study · Workers' comp spine

How Dr. Yasmeh helped a construction worker get back on the job site.

A 42-year-old construction worker came to LAOSS through a workers' comp referral after a lifting injury triggered an L5-S1 disc herniation and a screaming sciatic leg. Conservative care bought partial relief; an eventual microdiscectomy finished the job. Here's the full path — including the honest reality of how workers' comp authorization timelines shape the journey.

Workers' comp lumbar disc herniation case study — LAOSS microdiscectomy and conservative care progression
Patient case study

L5-S1 microdiscectomy.

Conservative care first, surgery when it became the right call — with WC paperwork handled end-to-end.

4 mo
Back to full-duty work
Treating surgeon
Dr. Siamak Yasmeh
★★★★★
L5-S1 microdiscectomy
Case snapshot
  • Chief complaint — Acute low-back pain and right-leg radiculopathy in a 42-year-old construction worker after a lifting injury on the job; MRI confirmed an L5-S1 disc herniation with right S1 nerve root compression.
  • Treatment path — 8 weeks of physical therapy, a short course of oral steroids, two epidural steroid injections spaced six weeks apart, then an L5-S1 microdiscectomy when leg symptoms only partially resolved.
  • Recovery — Discharged the same day, walking comfortably at week 1, back to modified-duty work at 8 weeks post-op, cleared for full-duty construction at 4 months.
  • Outcome — Full return to heavy-labor construction with no restrictions; leg pain resolved completely, residual mild low-back stiffness on long days.
  • Honest caveat — Workers' comp authorization added roughly six weeks to the diagnostic timeline. Our WC team handled every form; the patient paid nothing out of pocket. Not every WC spine case returns to full duty — this one did.
The presenting problem

A lifting injury that wouldn't quit.

Our patient was a journeyman framer on a multi-story residential project. The incident itself was unremarkable — a two-person carry of a sheathing bundle, an awkward pivot, an audible pop in his low back, and a wave of pain that ran down the back of his right thigh and into the outer foot by the end of the shift. He finished the day, drove home, slept badly, and called his foreman the next morning. He was sent to the on-site occupational clinic and started the workers' comp process.

By the time we saw him at LAOSS — about seven weeks after the injury, after the initial WC authorization for an orthopedic spine consult cleared — he had a textbook S1 radiculopathy. Sharp, electric pain down the posterior right leg, numbness on the outer foot, and a weak gastroc that buckled on toe-raises. His MRI, which had taken six weeks to authorize, showed a moderate-sized right paracentral L5-S1 disc herniation flattening the traversing S1 nerve root. History, exam, and imaging all agreed: this was a structural problem causing a neurological symptom in a patient who used his back for a living.

Conservative care, in order

What we tried before we talked about surgery.

Most lumbar disc herniations resolve without surgery within twelve weeks, and we never lead with the operating room when the natural history is on our side. Our patient started a structured eight-week course of physical therapy focused on neural mobilization, lumbar stabilization, and a graded return to activity. He was also placed on a short course of oral steroids during the first week to calm the acute inflammatory response around the nerve root.

When leg pain persisted at week four, we scheduled the first of two transforaminal epidural steroid injections, targeted to the right S1 foramen. He got real — but partial — relief, with the leg pain dropping from a reported eight out of ten down to about a four. A second injection six weeks later did less. By week sixteen post-injury, his back was tolerable but the leg was not, and the gastroc weakness on exam hadn't improved. We sat down together — with his WC adjuster on a three-way call — and laid out the options: continue managing, accept a likely permanent restriction, or proceed with a microdiscectomy. He wanted his job back. We agreed surgery was the right call.

Why we chose this path

Why an L5-S1 microdiscectomy was the right call.

Three things were true by the time we authorized surgery. Conservative care had been given a fair, fully documented trial of more than twelve weeks. The MRI continued to show the same compressive lesion, with no signs of resorption on a repeat scan. And the clinical picture — persistent radicular leg pain plus a measurable neurological deficit in a patient whose livelihood required heavy lifting — met every published indication for surgical decompression.

A microdiscectomy is the most conservative spine operation we offer. Through a roughly one-inch midline incision, we use an operating microscope to remove only the herniated disc fragment compressing the nerve root, preserving the rest of the disc and all surrounding bony anatomy. It is an outpatient procedure. There is no fusion, no hardware, no spine instrumentation. The published return-to-work data for microdiscectomy in workers' comp populations is favorable, and we had every reason to expect this patient would join that group.

Recovery milestones

His recovery roadmap.

Microdiscectomy recovery is fast by spine-surgery standards — but a return to heavy labor takes patience. These were the milestones he hit.

01Week 1

Calm the nerve

Discharged home the same day with oral analgesics. Walking encouraged from day one; lifting restricted to under ten pounds; no bending or twisting.

  • Walking 20-minute intervals by day 2
  • Leg pain dropped 70% within 48 hours
  • Off opioid pain medication by day 5
  • Incision check at 1 week, sutures out
02Month 1

Rebuild the core

Outpatient physical therapy 2 to 3 times a week, focused on lumbar stabilization, hip-hinge mechanics, and graded reloading.

  • Driving cleared at week 2 after off-narcotic verification
  • Walking 2 miles continuously by week 4
  • Light lifting (up to 25 lb) reintroduced at week 4
  • WC adjuster briefed on modified-duty timeline
03Month 6

Return to full duty

Modified-duty work began at 8 weeks; full unrestricted construction at 4 months; at 6 months the chart read like a closed case.

  • Modified duty (no lifting >40 lb) at week 8
  • Full-duty construction release at month 4
  • Functional capacity evaluation passed at month 4
  • No restrictions, no recurrence at one-year follow-up
Honest caveats

The workers' comp reality we owe every patient.

Workers' comp cases take longer to resolve than commercial-insurance cases, and we won't pretend otherwise. This patient waited roughly six weeks for the initial MRI authorization, several more weeks for each epidural injection authorization, and another two weeks for surgical authorization once we recommended microdiscectomy. None of that delay was clinical. All of it was administrative — the standard workers' comp utilization review process working as designed. Our LAOSS workers' comp team handled every form, every phone call, and every appeal end-to-end, and the patient never paid a dollar out of pocket. That part worked the way it's supposed to.

It's also worth saying clearly: not every workers' comp spine case ends at full-duty release. Some patients land at permanent modified-duty status. Some require lumbar fusion rather than microdiscectomy. Some have a herniation that recurs at the same level and need a second operation. This patient's trajectory — conservative care, single-level microdiscectomy, clean return to heavy labor — is a common outcome but not a guaranteed one. We had this conversation with him before surgery, not after.

Treating surgeon

Meet your spine specialist.

FAQ

Honest questions other workers' comp patients ask.

  • No. Authorized workers' compensation care is paid for by the WC insurance carrier, including office visits, imaging, injections, surgery, and physical therapy. You do not pay a copay, a deductible, or a coinsurance share. Our LAOSS workers' comp team handles every authorization request and appeal directly with the carrier.
  • Every step in a workers' comp claim — the initial consult, the MRI, each injection, the surgery itself — requires utilization review approval from the carrier before it can be scheduled. That review process commonly adds two to six weeks per step. None of that delay is clinical. We can't shortcut it, but we can manage the paperwork end-to-end so it doesn't fall on you.
  • Often, yes — especially for single-level lumbar disc herniations treated with microdiscectomy, the published return-to-work rates in workers' comp populations are favorable. But it depends on the lesion, the procedure, your recovery, and your job's physical demands. Some patients return to full duty, some to permanent modified duty, and a small minority don't return at all. We give every patient an honest read on their individual odds before surgery.
  • It's the most conservative lumbar spine operation we offer. Through a roughly one-inch incision, we remove only the disc fragment compressing the nerve root — no fusion, no hardware, no spine instrumentation. It's outpatient. Most patients are walking within hours and home the same day. The recovery is real, but it's nothing like a fusion.
  • That's a great outcome and it's how the majority of disc herniations resolve. We follow you to full recovery, document the resolution with your WC carrier, and discharge you back to full duty. Surgery is never the goal — it's the option we keep open if conservative care doesn't get you all the way there.
Injured on the job?

We handle the paperwork.

Our LAOSS workers' comp team manages every authorization, every form, and every carrier call — so you can focus on healing. Book a workers' comp spine consultation at any of our LA-area offices.

Booking now
21 specialists · 8 offices
Greater Los Angeles
On-site X-raySame visit
Most insurers acceptedIn-network

Composite case based on common LAOSS treatment outcomes. Anonymized for patient privacy.

Call usBook online